The Blog

Ever been offered an incentive at work and thought… is that really going to make a difference?

You’re asked to sell more, push a bit harder, maybe go the extra mile – but the reward doesn’t quite stack up. Or the scheme is so unclear you’re not even sure what you’d get if you did hit the target.

This comes up a lot when we talk to teams and leaders. Incentive schemes are everywhere, but they don’t always have the effect people expect.

So it’s worth asking a simple question:

How do incentives actually affect motivation and performance at work?

What is an incentive in the workplace?

In a business context, an incentive is something offered on top of basic pay to encourage extra effort.

That could be:

• Commission on sales
• A performance bonus
• Profit share
• Financial rewards linked to targets

The intention is straightforward – create a reason for people to do more.

But whether that works depends on how the scheme is designed.

Why incentive schemes don’t always motivate people

Most organisations already expect a good level of effort as part of the job. Where incentives come in is that extra push – more sales, more output, more engagement.

The challenge is that not every scheme creates that response.

Here are some of the patterns we see.

When the scheme is hard to follow

If people can’t quickly work out what they’ll earn from their efforts, they tend to switch off from it.

Clear schemes tend to answer one simple question: “If I do this, what do I get?”

When that link isn’t obvious, the scheme fades into the background.

When it doesn’t feel fair

Fairness carries a lot of weight. If someone sees a colleague earning more for what looks like less effort, or doesn’t understand how figures have been worked out, it can create frustration that lingers.

Even a well-intended scheme can lose credibility if people don’t trust it.

When it rewards the wrong outcome

A common issue is focusing on volume instead of value.

For example:

• Paying per customer rather than revenue
• Rewarding quantity without considering quality

That can lead to situations where lower-value work is rewarded more highly than stronger commercial results.

When rewards feel out of reach

Some schemes only pay out after a certain threshold is hit.

If someone feels too far away from that point, motivation can dip: “There’s no point this month, I’ll start again next time.”

A more consistent connection between effort and reward tends to keep momentum going.

When it becomes a short-term game

Short-term incentive schemes can encourage short-term behaviour.

People adjust how they work to hit targets in the moment – sometimes in ways that don’t help the business longer term.

A longer-running approach often leads to steadier, more sustainable performance.

Incentives vs perks: why the difference matters

Workplace perks often get grouped in with incentives.

Things like:

• Free lunches
• Gym memberships
• Team events

They can improve the working environment, but they don’t usually change day-to-day performance.

Incentives are more closely tied to output. People can see the connection between what they do and what they receive.

That link is where motivation tends to build.

What actually drives motivation at work?

Incentives play a part, but they sit alongside other factors.

From what we see in organisations, motivation is influenced by:

• Feeling recognised for contributions
• A sense of fairness in how people are treated and rewarded
• Clarity around expectations
• Belief in what the business is doing and where it’s going

Recognition, in particular, has a strong impact. When effort is noticed and acknowledged – alongside financial reward – engagement tends to increase.

Designing an incentive scheme that works

There isn’t a single model that fits every organisation, but strong schemes tend to have a few things in common.

They are:

• Clear – easy to explain and easy to understand
• Fair – people can see how outcomes are calculated
• Relevant – linked to the outcomes that matter to the business
• Consistent – not constantly changing or resetting
• Balanced – combining financial reward with recognition

Simplicity often makes the biggest difference. When people understand how the scheme works, they’re more likely to engage with it.

A quick sense-check for leaders

If you’re reviewing an incentive scheme, it’s worth asking:

• Can the team explain how it works without checking a document?
• Does it reward the behaviours and results you actually want?
• Does it feel fair across different roles and performance levels?
• Would you feel motivated by it yourself?

If there’s hesitation around any of those, it’s usually a sign something needs adjusting.

Final thought

Incentives are meant to encourage people to stretch their performance.

When the link between effort and reward is clear – and feels fair – people tend to lean into it.

When that link is missing or unclear, most people will still do their job well… just without going much further.

You can listen to our conversation about Incentives, Rewards and Motivation in The Reality of Business here, or wherever you get your podcasts.

If you’re looking at your incentive structure and thinking it could be doing more, we can help you sense-check it.

Let’s talk.